The Notebook is not a subtle film. It is a romantic melodrama that announces its intentions in its first frame and pursues them relentlessly for 124 minutes. What elevates it above similar material is Ryan Gosling and Rachel McAdams’s chemistry and a sincerity that refuses to be embarrassed by what it is asking of you.
Noah Calhoun (Gosling) and Allie Hamilton (McAdams) fall in love one summer in 1940s South Carolina. She is wealthy; he is not. Her parents disapprove. Circumstance separates them. Seven years pass. She is engaged to another man. He has restored the old house she loved. She comes back.
The present-day framing, an older man (James Garner) reading a notebook to a woman with dementia (Gena Rowlands), is the film’s most emotionally generous element. Their late-film revelation is earned because they have made you believe in seventy years of love.
This is a film that knows what it wants to do and does it with complete conviction. Sometimes that is exactly enough.



