The Holdovers is an old-fashioned film in the best possible sense. It has no ambitions beyond telling its small story beautifully, and in doing that with such care and wit, it achieves something rare: it makes you feel like you have spent time with real people.
Paul Giamatti plays Paul Hunham, a classics teacher at a New England boarding school in 1970, widely disliked, relentlessly exacting, and deeply lonely under layers of misanthropy. When most students go home for Christmas, a handful remain. Through circumstance and spite, Hunham ends up responsible for one student, Angus Tully (Dominic Sessa), and joined by the school’s head cook Mary Lamb (Da’Vine Joy Randolph), recently bereaved.
Giamatti is magnificent. He makes Hunham’s defenses visible from the first scene but never telegraphs the man’s warmer depths until exactly the right moment. It is a performance of real intelligence. Dominic Sessa, in his debut feature, matches him scene for scene. Their dynamic, all antagonism and then slow, grudging recognition, is the engine of the film.
Da’Vine Joy Randolph won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress, and it was fully deserved. She carries grief with a quiet dignity that gives the film its deepest notes.
Alexander Payne shoots the film with a slightly grainy texture that evokes the period without becoming pastiche. It feels like a film that has always existed, which is exactly the right feeling for a story about connection across time.


