Rating: 8/10 | Director: Alexander Payne | Runtime: 133 min | Released: November 2023
Alexander Payne hasn’t made a film this good since Sideways. The Holdovers is the kind of movie that sneaks up on you, it starts as a dry comedy about a miserable prep school classics teacher, and by the third act it has quietly become something about grief and purpose and the specific loneliness of feeling like you exist outside of your own time.
The Setup
Christmas break, 1970. Barton Academy, a Massachusetts boarding school for boys whose families can afford to send them somewhere cold and prestigious. Paul Hunham (Paul Giamatti) is the school’s ancient history teacher, demanding, socially impossible, almost universally disliked by students and colleagues alike. He’s assigned to supervise the handful of students who aren’t going home for the holiday. One of them, Angus Tully (Dominic Sessa), is a bright, angry kid with enough problems of his own to fill a separate film. Mary Lamb (Da’Vine Joy Randolph), the school’s head cook, is grieving her son, killed in Vietnam. These three get snowed in together for two weeks, and something shifts.
Paul Giamatti Is Doing Something Rare
The performance is a masterclass in the kind of specificity that turns a type, the curmudgeon, the stickler, the difficult man, into an actual person. Hunham is not redeemed in the way that character type usually gets redeemed. He doesn’t become warm or learn to open up in some climactic way. What happens is subtler and more interesting: he is seen. By Angus. By Mary. In small ways. And the film shows you what that costs him to allow.
There’s a scene midway through the film where Hunham explains, quietly and without self-pity, why he ended up teaching at a school that makes him miserable instead of the academic career he was pointed toward. Giamatti plays it with his eyes mostly on the floor. It’s one of the best two minutes of acting in any film this year.
Da’Vine Joy Randolph Steals Every Scene
Mary Lamb’s grief is present in every scene she’s in, not performed as tragedy but carried as weight. Randolph plays a woman who is still functioning, still working, still responsible, while inside something enormous has broken. The scene at the local bar near Christmas, where she dances alone and the camera just watches her, is extraordinary. It’s the kind of performance that makes you angry the film didn’t center around her.
Dominic Sessa in His First Film
Sessa was cast directly from Deerfield Academy, an actual boarding school, with no prior acting credits. He’s completely convincing. Angus is written as someone who is difficult because he’s in pain, and Sessa plays the difficult parts without making you lose sympathy for the pain underneath them. His relationship with Hunham develops along lines that feel earned rather than scripted, and the dynamic between them by the final act carries real emotional weight.
The Period Detail
Payne and cinematographer Eigil Bryld shoot the film to look like it was made in 1970, using grain, color timing, and aspect ratio choices that read as period rather than nostalgia-bait. The effect is immersive. This is a film that lives in its setting rather than visiting it.
The Verdict
The Holdovers is a warm film about difficult people. That’s harder to make than it sounds. It’s funny when it needs to be, sad when it earns it, and patient enough to let the characters become real before asking you to care about them. Alexander Payne is back, and it matters.

