0 Comments

Rating: 9.5/10 | Director: Martin McDonagh | Runtime: 114 min | Released: October 2022

Martin McDonagh set The Banshees of Inisherin on a small Irish island in 1923, during the Irish Civil War, and the war on the mainland barely registers. What happens on Inisherin is smaller and somehow bigger: one man decides he no longer wants to be friends with the man he has been friends with his entire life, and the other man cannot accept it. That is the whole story. It is one of the best films of this decade.

The Setup

Colm Doherty (Brendan Gleeson) wakes up one morning and tells Pádraic Súilleabháin (Colin Farrell) that he no longer wishes to spend time with him. He does not hate Pádraic. He finds him dull. Life is short, he says, and he wants to spend what remains of it composing music rather than sitting in the pub listening to a man who has nothing interesting to say.

This rejection destroys Pádraic. He is not a complicated man and he knows it, but he has always understood himself to be kind, and kindness has always seemed to him like enough. The film’s early passages are almost comic in how literally Pádraic refuses to accept the situation. He keeps walking up to Colm. He knocks on doors. He asks mutual friends what he did wrong. He did nothing wrong. That is the point, and also the wound.

The Performances

Colin Farrell gives a career performance. He plays Pádraic as a man whose simple goodness is not a limitation but a genuine thing, and watching that goodness erode across the film is genuinely painful. There is a moment in the second half where Pádraic makes a decision that marks a real change in who he is, and Farrell plays it without announcement or melodrama. He just becomes someone slightly different, and you feel the loss of who he was.

Brendan Gleeson is equally precise. Colm is not a villain. He is a man who has made a calculation about his own remaining time and decided that one particular relationship is not worth what it costs him. That the calculation is cruel does not make it irrational, and Gleeson never lets you hate him cleanly. You understand Colm even as his rigidity escalates into something genuinely ugly.

Barry Keoghan, as the island’s resident oddity Dominic Kearney, walks away with every scene he is in. His character is the only one who sees the situation clearly from outside it, and what happens to him lands harder because of that clarity.

What McDonagh Is Actually Doing

The film uses the backdrop of the Civil War deliberately. Ireland is killing itself over a dispute that will look, from any sufficient distance, as meaningless as two men in a pub no longer speaking. McDonagh does not underline this. He lets the cannon fire drift across the water in the background and trusts you to feel the parallel without being told what to feel about it.

What the film is most precisely about is what happens when one person in a relationship decides it is over and the other person refuses to accept that decision. The ending is not a resolution. It is a resting point, two men who have destroyed things between them that cannot be rebuilt, settling into a kind of cold truce with the wreckage. It is one of the most honest endings in recent cinema.

The Banshees of Inisherin is the kind of film that rewards a second viewing because what looks like Irish dark comedy on the surface is, underneath, a film about grief, stubbornness, time, and what we owe each other. It is McDonagh’s best work, and it will last.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts